In existographies, Etienne Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire (1722-1844) (IQ:#|#) (Cattell 1000:481) (EvT:9|21+) (CR:9), or "Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire" (Darwin, 1860s) or "Geoffroy St. Hilaire" (Haeckel, 1899), was a French naturalist noted for his 1795-1833 views on the origin and form change of animals, characterized as a "deism-based materialistic evolutionary determinism" theory of species origins (Hecht, 2003). [2]
Overview
In 1830, there was a famous confrontation, or public collision, between the creationism theist Georges Cuvier and Hilaire, at the French Academy of Sciences; Adrian Desmond, in his The Politics of Evolution (1989) retrospectively describes the encounter as follows: [3]
“The famous 1830 confrontation between Georges Cuvier and Geoffroy Hilaire, at the French Academy of Sciences, was in effect a collision between Hilaire’s ‘coldly deterministic views (see: chilling effect) of animal form and evolution and Cuvier’s ‘extreme views’ that animals were broken into discrete ‘divisions’.”
Goethe’s last writings were said to have been devoted to defending Saint-Hilaire. [4]
Great problem of natural philosophy
In circa 1836, Saint-Hilaire stated the so-called great problem of natural philosophy as follows: [1]
“It is quite certain that there was a moment when life did not exist on our planet, and another moment when it appeared. It is the passage between these two states that forms the great problem of natural philosophy today.”
This problem was solved in 2009 by Libb Thims.
Darwin
Saint-Halaire, of note, was one of three people, along with Johann Goethe (1784) and Erasmus Darwin (1791), cited by English naturalist Charles Darwin in his 1859 Origin of Species as having been a forerunner to his own evolution theory.
Quotes | By
The following are related quotes:
“Can the organization of vertebrated animals be referred to one uniform type?”
— Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire (1818), Anatomical Philosophy (Ѻ)
“The external world is all-powerful in alteration of the form of organized bodies.. . these [modifications] are inherited, and they influence all the rest of the organization of the animal, because if these modifications lead to injurious effects, the animals which exhibit them perish and are replaced by others of a somewhat different form, a form changed so as to be adapted to the new environment.”
— Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire (c.1830) (Ѻ)
“Of the two theories on the development of organs, one supposes the preexistence of the germs and their indefinite nesting; the other admits their successive formation and their evolution in the course of ages.”
— Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire (1833), “Article” [1]
“Influence of the surrounding world changes animal forms..”
— Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire (1833) (Ѻ)
See also
● Scientific revolutions
References
1. Guyader, Herve Le. (2004). Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire: a Visionary Naturalist (Note 13: to page 281). University of Chicago Press.
2. Hecht, Jennifer M. (2003). Doubt: A History: The Great Doubters and Their Legacy of Innovation from Socrates and Jesus to Thomas (pgs. 403). HarperOne.
3. Desmond, Adrian. (1989). The Politics of Evolution: Morphology, Medicine, and Reform in Radical London (pg. 9). University of Chicago Press.
4. Frenay, Robert. (2006). Pulse: the Coming Age of Systems and Machines Inspiried by Living Things (pg. 12). MacMillan.
External links
● Etienne Saint-Hilaire – Wikipedia.