A depiction (Ѻ) of Plato’s cave wherein, at left, prisoners are chained to a wall watching the "manufactured reality" of a puppet play, and, at right, three prisoners have broken free from their chains, and escaped to the "true reality" of the outside world. |
§5. A man on board a ship, gliding in a calm sea, may imagine himself to be at rest, and think and act upon that supposition with the utmost propriety; because, though not absolutely at rest, he is relatively so. He afterwards, however, on going ashore, sits down, and, smiling at his mistake, says, ‘Now I See my error; I have not been at rest till now.’ But still he is mistaken; for the earth itself on which he sits or stands, is in motion round the sun. ‘Well, then,’ says he, ‘the sun at any rate is at rest.’ ‘Not so,’ says the well-informed astronomer; ‘the sun also, and the whole solar system, are in motion through absolute space.’ But here the person who was first deceived in the ship asks the astronomer, ‘What proof have you that the universe itself is fixed in absolute space? or what is it you call absolute? I have already been three times deceived by adopting that-term; and will henceforth ascribe the title of absolute to no created being.’ What has thus been said regarding motion, is true also regarding thought. In human knowledge, there is nothing absolute; no fixed principles; no standard to which we can appeal.”
“The accepted belief in the theory of life is similar to Plato’s 400BC allegory of the cave. The person in the cave looks at the two shadows: (a) people walking in the sunlight and making shadows of walking people on the cave wall; (b) a person with moving puppets in the sunlight, making shadows of walking people on the cave wall. The person in the cave will look upon the shadows and naively conclude that ‘yes both shadows, a and b, are indicative that two different 'alive' entities outside the cave.’ The allegory of the molecular cave is the same. Wherever we see something that we deem as “alive”, be it a walking kinesin (6-element molecule) or a walking human (26-element molecule), we will always be able to look through the atomic telescope and see only an energy-driven molecule. In other words, belief that one of the molecules is alive is the same as belief in puppeteer’s animated shadow.”— Libb Thims (2010), dialogue (Ѻ) with Georgi Gladyshev on the origin of life (see: defunct theory of life), Dec 6