Above: the annual pilgrimage to Mecca (hajj), something that must be done at least once during a Muslim’s reaction extent (lifetime), as one of the five "pillars" or basic acts in Islam. Right: the 2011 Islam’s Quantum Question, by Nidhal Guessoum, showing a depiction of iron fillings around a magnet alluding to a comparison of Kaaba (cuboid building at center) and its “black stone” (eastern cornerstone) to the magnet and humans, in Islamic belief, aligned towards the Kaaba, like the aligned iron filings (see: Ising model of human behavior). [1] |
See main: Islamic atheismIn Islam, atheists, among whom are mostly closet atheists (as open atheists in the Muslim world tend to be killed) are categorized as kafir (كافر), which carries connotations of blasphemy and disconnection from the Islamic community; a term, to note, that is also used to describe polytheists (shirk), and that translates roughly as "denier" or "concealer". In Arabic, "atheism" is generally translated ilhad (إلحاد), although this also means "heresy". (Ѻ). In the 14th century, the top three heretics or Islamic atheists were al-Marri (c.1020), aka the "Arab Lucretius", Ibn al Rawandi (c.870), a three impostors advocate, and Abu Hayyan (923-1023) (Ѻ), noted for his dialogue (Ѻ) on “why atheists do good work?” if, e.g., they have they have no fear of a final reckoning, do not seek to be rewarded by god or even expect even to return to god? The gist of their atheism rep was summarized as follows:
“The heretics in Islam are three: Ibn al Rawandi, Abu Hayyan al Tawhidi, and Abu Alaa al-Ma’arri–of them, mostly Abu Hayyan, because they (attempt to) edify grandiloquence but in fact they babble.”— Ibn al-Jawziyyah (c.1325) [6]
The 11 Feb 2018 interaction between two Muslims and an atheist, during which once the atheist says he believes in big bang and doesn't believe in god, they kick him off the show. |
Sheikh Mahmoud: Why did you become an atheist?
Ex-Muslim Atheist: Because there is no scientific evidence for god.
Muslim Host: How can you say that. Who created you? Who made you exist as a human being?
Sheikh Mahmoud: Do you know how you were created?
Ex-Muslim Atheist: There are many theories explaining our existence on this planet …
Sheikh Mahmoud: I’m asking you a question. How did you become a human being?
Muslim Host: How come you exist in this universe?
Ex-Muslim Atheist: Ok. Let me explain. There are theories that try to explain our existence. One theory is that god created us. Okay? But there are other theories, with much more evidence, like big bang theory.
Muslim Host: Speak Arabic! You are in Egypt. And you are addressing simple people, so don’t use big words for no reason.
Ex-Muslim Atheist: I’m using these terms because science is conducted in English.
Muslim Host: What science are you talking about, you are confusing and unreliable. You deny the existence of god and reject our religion and principles.
Ex-Muslim Atheist: Is this so bad?
Muslim Host: Of course, you come here to talk about a certain idea, but have nothing to offer. You offer atheism! You offer heresy! I apologize to the viewers for having an Egyptian of this kind on our show. I’m sorry, Mohammad, but you cannot stay with us on the show. Because your ideas are inappropriate, I’m sad to say. We cannot promote such destructive ideas. You have not uttered a single convincing word.
Sheikh Mahmoud: Look, dear Mohammad, you need psychiatric treatment. Many young people today suffer from mental illnesses, due to material or mental circumstances.
Muslim Host: It’s like Sheikh Mahmoud says, have you seen a psychiatrist? I advise you to leave the studio and go straight to a psychiatric hospital. You shouldn’t be here. Unfortunately, I cannot let you be here anymore. Please get up and leave, and I will continue the show with Dr. Mahmoud. Unfortunately, your ideas are destructive and bad for Egyptian youth. You are a bad example of Egyptian youth. … Mohammad, you can’t stay here. I advise you to go straight to a psychiatric hospital.
See also: Muhammad never existedLittle, to note, has been published on the historicity of the Quran, say as compared to the historicity of the Bible, presently known to have written by some 52+ scholars, collectively, over the course of some 600 years (500BC-100AD).
“Myth as a constituent of Arab-Islamic culture has long been ignored or even denied.”— Jaroslav Stetkevych (2000), Muhammad and the Golden Bough: Reconstructing Arabian Myth (pg. ix)
“Christianity and Islam made it illegal and immoral to think for a long time, and that’s why philosophy and science slumbered for centuries. That fact is proven by the simple fact that I could not find a philosophy book at a bookstore when I visited Istanbul, Turkey. Turkey is now a Muslim nation so it’s hard to find books by philosophers out on display at libraries or bookstores.”— Monydit Malieth (2013), The Future Affects the Past [1]
“The Koran = Mein Kampf of the prophet Mohammad.”— Micheal Sturzenberge (2016), Munich interaction (Ѻ), Mar 3
A statue and quote by Omar Khayyam, noted unbeliever. |
“Who burned the books of Averroes? Who banished Alhazen? Who accused Avicenna and Ibn Al-Khwarizmi of heresy? Was it Israel or America?! They didn’t even exist back then. We did. Let’s be honest about it.”— Ibrahim Al-Buleihi (2010), Al-Arabiya TV (Dubai/Saudi Arabia) part one (Ѻ); part two (Ѻ)(Ѻ), Feb 26; Nasser Dashti, supposedly, is a younger version of him; see: Middle Ages genius; among other (Ѻ) comments
“We Arabs and Muslims are backward, but we don't know it.”— Saudi Cleric (2016), Mermi TV translated debate, Sep 1 (Ѻ)
“How come the Europeans, Americans, and Japanese are never possessed by ‘Jinns’?— Khaled Montaser (c.2017), Publication (Ѻ)